My Favorite Pizza Joints in Erie, PA

Erie, Pennsylvania, may not top the list of famous pizza cities like New York or Chicago, yet this city hides some truly remarkable places for pizza aficionados. Growing up with the rich, savory flavors of South Jersey tomato pies, I’ve embarked on a quest to find the best pizzas that Erie has to offer. Here are my top picks that every pizza lover should check out.

Stevo’s Pizza: A Deep-Dish Delight

Stevo’s Pizza is the go-to place for those who cherish the deep-dish variety that’s reminiscent of classic Jersey tomato pies. Their pizzas stand out for their thick, hearty crusts that are both flavorful and deeply satisfying. It’s the kind of place where every bite feels like a nod to the traditional art of pizza making, making it a must-visit for anyone who appreciates a good, substantial pizza.

Virgil’s Plate: The Thin-Crust Innovator

At Virgil’s Plate, the pizza is anything but ordinary. Known for their thin-crust square pizzas, they offer a distinct twist on the classic pizza formula. Their BLT pizza, in particular, is a revelation with the unexpected yet utterly perfect topping of fresh lettuce and tomato, adding a crisp freshness that complements the savory base beautifully. It’s a unique flavor combination that works surprisingly well, making Virgil’s Plate a standout spot in Erie’s pizza scene.

Valerio’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria: A Taste of Tradition

For those seeking a classic pizza experience, look no further than Valerio’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria. This iconic establishment is celebrated for its buttery, flavorful crusts that seem to transport you directly to an old-school Italian pizzeria. The attention to detail and dedication to quality at Valerio’s ensure that each pizza is a masterpiece of taste and texture, embodying the timeless appeal of traditional Italian pizza-making. Discover more about Valerio’s

Erie, PA, might not have the pizza reputation of larger cities, but it certainly holds its own with these exceptional spots. Each place brings something unique to the table, from deep-dish comforts to innovative thin-crust creations and classic Italian craftsmanship. So, the next time you’re in Erie and craving a slice, be sure to give these places a try. And if you have other favorites in Erie that deserve a shoutout, I’d love to hear about them!